‘She asked if she could stay with me again “just for a bit.” I told her no right away’: Older sister refuses to host her sister again after a “two-week” breakup stay turned into 9 rent-free months of mess, borrowed clothes, and eaten groceries

5 months ago 45

Want Your Business Featured Here?

Get instant exposure to our readers

Chat on WhatsApp
  • AITJ for refusing to let my sister move in after she treated my place like a free hotel last time?

    Stressed woman pinching the bridge of her nose while another cheerful woman beside her points to herself, creating a contrast between frustration and upbeat self-focused energy

    Image is representative only and does not depict the actual subjects of the story.

  • A few years ago, my younger sister (28F) asked if she could stay with me (32F) after a breakup.

  • Now a new housing issue pops up and the old pattern knocks on the door again. Same sister, same request, same casual script. Just for a bit. No mention of money, chores, or how last time ended in public guilt posts and family drama. Mom applies emotional pressure from the sidelines, and the family group chat suddenly discovers the word selfish at the exact moment boundaries show up. None of them offered their own couch.  

  • She said it would be "two weeks, max." I had the space and didn't want her stressing, so I agreed.

  • She ended up staying for nine months. She never paid rent or utilities even though she had a full-time job.

  • She left dirty dishes everywhere, borrowed my clothes without asking, constantly ate the groceries | bought, and invited people over like it was her apartment.

  • woman in a bright blue turtleneck sweater pointing at herself with a surprised, confident expression against a yellow background

    Image is representative only and does not depict the actual subjects of the story.

  • Every time I tried to set boundaries, she'd get defensive or act offended. When I finally told her she needed to move out, she made a big scene online about "certain people only caring when it's convenient." That caused drama in the family for a while.

  •  her lease is ending, she doesn't like her roommates, and she asked if she could stay with me again "just for a bit." I told her no right away.

  • I'm not putting myself through that again. She got mad and called me "heartless." My mom keeps telling me I should let her stay just this once, and my sister has been posting vague stuff online about being "let down by people she counts on." I told them I'd help her look for a new place or movers, but she's not living with me.

  • So the offer this time is clean. Help finding a place. Help with movers. No free rerun of the 9-month residency. In this particular family, love is loud, but memory is short. Sometimes, the kindest thing a sister can do for everyone involved is keep the door locked and the phone on mute.

  • Stressed woman sitting on a couch with her eyes closed, pinching the bridge of her nose in frustration while wearing a cozy knit sweater

    Image is representative only and does not depict the actual subjects of the story.

  • Now most of the family chat is calling me selfish.

  • Consistent-Ad3191 If your mother has a problem, maybe she should help her if she has a full-time job then maybe she should get her own place. Or find another roommate.

  • OP honeytwirlbeam Right? She's fully capable of finding another option, I'm not doing it for her again.

  • mariehotwife84 Absolutely NTA. She had her chance before and made your home miserable. Saying no now isn't cruel, it's self-preservation. You can offer support without letting her take over your life again. Anyone criticizing you clearly hasn't experienced something like this.

  • OP honeytwirlbeam I can still help in ways that don't turn my apartment into her free hotel. I've tried being nice before and it backfired.

  • Childless_Catlady42 Why can't she stay with mom just this once?

  • OP honeytwirlbeam Because last time she stayed with mom, it caused so much drama and chaos. Mom was stressed out, I was stressed out and honestly no one really got a break.

  • HuntAccurate9397 NTA and I'm hazarding a guess that it's the room mates that don't like your sister!

  • OP honeytwirlbeam I had the same thought. Even if she doesn't vibe with them, I'm not going to deal with another messy stay.

  • Ok_Professional6307 NTJ. Your sister has already proven that she doesn't respect you or your home. If your mom and other family members are so concerned about it they can let her move in with them. They won't do that though because it's fine for your sister to disrespect you and your home but they won't let her do it to them. I can't stand when someone says "family helps family" or "do it to keep the peace" and then isn't willing to do it themselves. You are not being selfish by saying no. You h

  • OP honeytwirlbeam Thanks. I can't keep repeating the same chaos and stress just to keep the peace. That's not fair to me.

  • BidRevolutionary945 She can move in w/ your mom or other family members this time. After all family is family.

  • FreeGaza Today let your mom or those other family members let your sis live with them.

  • //www.reddit.com/r/BestofR

  • Remarkable_Side2323 Exactly

Tags

Scroll Down For The Next Article

Trending Now

 'He said I should stay on top of communication if I want to grow.'

22-year-old employee refuses to respond to work messages after 8 PM because her boss got angry she didn't respond to his message at 11:40 PM: 'He said I should stay on top of communication if I want to grow.'

 'They weren't there the next morning, or the day after'

17-year-old declines to go on family camping trip, protests when they stay 4 days longer than expected and he runs out of food: 'They weren't there the next morning, or the day after'

 'He ignores my birthdays, he ignores me at Christmas, he never invites me to parties.'

17-year-old refuses to cook meals for his estranged 28-year-old brother and his 3 kids after he ignored him his entire life: 'He ignores my birthdays, he ignores me at Christmas, he never invites me to parties.'

 'Of the like 100 shows he’s played in our home state, I’ve gone to 90-95 of them'

31-year-old musician husband calls out wife for not attending every one of his shows, not buying tickets right when they drop: 'Of the like 100 shows he’s played in our home state, I’ve gone to 90-95 of them'

 'Not giving Emily a safe transition'

Helicopter-mother demands that her sister let her sheltered teen daughter, Emily, move into her spare bedroom as a "practice dorm" for the 8 months before college, niece begs aunt to refuse, sparking family tension: 'Not giving Emily a safe transition'

 ‘Then I gave him our parents' key'

Sibling changes the lock to their house after parents give a key to 34-year-old unemployed brother, refusing to let him stay: ‘Then I gave him our parents' key'

Read Entire Article