As you walk through the bustling streets of Lahore, you might have noticed children, women, and men approaching you with an assortment of small items, from flowers and pencils to toys and books. While they may appear to be vendors, selling their wares, a closer look reveals a more insidious reality – they are begging, using the guise of selling small items to solicit sympathy and donations.
Background & Context
Pakistan has a significant problem of street children, with the United Nations Children's Fund (UNICEF) estimating that over 1.5 million children live on the streets, with many more vulnerable to exploitation and abuse. The issue is particularly acute in major cities like Lahore, where poverty, lack of education, and limited job opportunities push many families to desperate measures.
The phenomenon of children and adults selling small items on the streets, often in crowded markets and on major roads, has become increasingly common in cities like Lahore, Faisalabad, and Multan. While some may view it as a harmless way to earn a living, experts warn that it is a form of begging, which can lead to exploitation, abuse, and long-term psychological damage.
Key Details
A recent study by researchers at the University of Okara found that the majority of children and adults selling small items on the streets in Punjab are not actually earning a living wage. Instead, they are using the guise of selling items to solicit sympathy and donations, often with the help of organized gangs. The study also found that the tactics used by these individuals include exploiting people's emotions, highlighting their poverty and desperation, and even using fake stories to elicit sympathy.
According to the study, the average age of children involved in this form of begging is around 12 years old, with many being forced to work on the streets by their parents or guardians. The researchers also found that the items being sold are often of little value, with some children selling items for as little as Rs. 10-20 (approximately $0.10-$0.20 USD).
In an interview, Dr. Aisha Iram Murtaza, a psychologist at Fountain House Lahore, explained that the phenomenon of begging in disguise is often driven by emotional manipulation. "When people see a child or a vulnerable individual, they are more likely to respond emotionally, rather than rationally. This can lead to a situation where people are willing to donate money or buy items at an inflated price, simply to alleviate their own feelings of guilt or sympathy."
What Experts Say
According to experts, the issue of begging in disguise is not just a matter of individual sympathy, but a complex problem that requires a broader societal response. "It's not just about giving or not giving money," said Syed Qosur, the founder of Sustainable Social Development Organization (SSDO). "It's about understanding the root causes of poverty, exploitation, and abuse, and working to address them in a systemic way."
Dr. Iram Murtaza also emphasized the need for a more nuanced approach to addressing the issue. "Rather than simply giving money or buying items from street vendors, we need to support organizations that provide education, job training, and social services to vulnerable individuals and families."
Key Takeaways
- The phenomenon of begging in disguise is a growing concern in major cities like Lahore, where children and adults sell small items on the streets to solicit sympathy and donations.
- The average age of children involved in this form of begging is around 12 years old, with many being forced to work on the streets by their parents or guardians.
- The items being sold are often of little value, with some children selling items for as little as Rs. 10-20 (approximately $0.10-$0.20 USD).
- Experts warn that the issue of begging in disguise is not just a matter of individual sympathy, but a complex problem that requires a broader societal response.
What This Means For You
As a citizen of Lahore or any other major city in Punjab, you can play a role in addressing the issue of begging in disguise. Rather than giving money or buying items from street vendors, consider supporting organizations that provide education, job training, and social services to vulnerable individuals and families.
By working together, we can create a more just and equitable society, where everyone has access to opportunities and resources. So, the next time you're approached by a child or adult selling small items on the street, take a moment to think about the broader implications, and consider supporting a more sustainable solution.
.png)
3 months ago
33




English (US) ·