‘Dig’ Review: Amy Poehler and Mike Schur Reunite for Peacock’s Likable but Underwhelming Archeology Comedy

22 minutes ago 2

Want Your Business Featured Here?

Get instant exposure to our readers

Chat on WhatsApp

According to PsychologistWorld.com, the website most successful at gaming the Google algorithm and therefore appearing first when you search for nocturnal interpretations, dreaming about falling into a pit denotes “deep sorrow.”

Perhaps it’s the lingering impact of rooting for Boston sports teams in the early ’90s, but Michael Schur has a fixation on pits and the consequences of falling into them that probably requires further examination.

Dig

The Bottom Line Can you dig it? Sure, though maybe not a lot.

Airdate: Monday, November 23
Cast: Amy Poehler, Hugh Laurie, Fina Strazza, Geraldine Viswanathan, Antonia Thomas
Creators: Mike Schur and Amy Poehler

More than 17 years after a poorly monitored pit supplied the inciting events for NBC’s beloved Parks and Recreation, Schur gazes once more into the abyss to trigger the story behind Peacock’s Dig, a comedy that might as well be called Parks and Excavation given that its ensemble is led by Parks star Amy Poehler, also a co-creator here.

It’s a comparison that’s inevitable and will inevitably spark disappointment; Dig is a pleasantly likable comedy, but it’s never hugely funny like Schur’s The Good Place (and what is Hell if not a theological pit?) nor is it deeply poignant like Schur’s A Man on the Inside (and what is aging if not the existential pit that comes for us all?). It’s a minor disappointment. The cast is too good and the vibe too amiable to incite any real antipathy. Still, there’s an ideal next gear, be it zaniness or sentiment, that Dig never finds.

Poehler plays Elise, second in command at an archeological dig site in coastal Greece. The various trenches are apparently primarily used as a summer program attracting American undergrads hoping to drink, flirt and occasionally uncover relics from a bygone civilization.

The program is supervised by renowned archeologist Neville Wycombe (Hugh Laurie), but he mostly makes morning announcements, absorbs the adulation of the “Ugs” and threatens to retire, only to stick around. It’s Elise who makes everything function, but her short fuse and occasional notes of contempt for her young charges render her less than ideal for the top spot she craves.

Elise is slightly more comfortable around the staff, including the privileged Clare (Antonia Thomas), who helps curate the trinkets found by the undergraduates. Perhaps Elise’s impatience with the younger characters stems from a nebulously bad first marriage — she’s now in a perpetual flirtation with the neighboring town’s gregarious mayor (Kayvan Novak’s Stavros) — or the betrayal of former student Dylan (Geraldine Viswanathan), who abruptly left shortly before they were supposed to go start their own dig together five years earlier.

Now Dylan is back, determined to set things right with Elise and with Barry (Jon Pointing), a former flame now engaged to Clare.

Adding confusion and lots of pratfalls is Patty (Fina Strazza), a farm girl with limited social skills and an abiding love for Disney movies and mythology. Patty arrives as Neville’s new assistant, one of several jobs she really isn’t qualified for.

The series, based on Kate Myers’ novel Excavations, probably works best as a group hang comedy about people committed to a serious pursuit that isn’t always valued by the world at large — you know, a bit like Parks and Recreation. But rather than sticking to the simplicity of a setting that’s basically a glorified summer camp, the series complicates things when Elise and Dylan make a discovery that leads to a mystery that turns everything upside down and forces everybody to learn very important lessons about themselves.

Some shots of pretty beaches and white plastered villages aside, most of Dig has a soundstage feeling. Even the archeological trenches themselves are artificial-looking, less than ideal given how much time we spend in them. But Dig quickly becomes more about a mystery with “Don’t steal cultural treasures!” as the underpinning than about archeology in literal or even metaphorical form. Schur did far better at mystery-crafting on A Man on the Inside, especially in its first season.

The pilot, which isn’t bad (none of the 10 episodes are) but is definitely clunky, introduces us to the main characters pretty much by having other people tell them things about their personalities that they presumably already know.

“I know your default setting is tough love, but please just learn to give people some grace,” Neville tells Elise.

“It’s like you’re from a fairy tale of neglected children lost in the forest,” Clare tells Dylan, whose chaotic energy is noticeable even to random baristas.

Etc.

The problem is that the characters, despite their exposition-heavy introductions, are oddly fuzzy, and the performances don’t always match the way the characters are described.

There’s a logic to the way Elise, Clare, Dylan and Patty are constructed. They are four women on the cusp of transition. Elise, age unspecified, is wondering if she’s ever going to get the opportunity to go from supporting player to the lead in her own life. Clare is 39, and she’s wondering if she’s ready to step out of the shadow of her mother’s wealth and become a grown-up on her own terms. Dylan is 29, and she thinks it’s time to develop some maturity. And Patty is 19, kept in perpetual childhood by her upbringing but ready for a lot of life milestones that more mainstream kids experienced five or 10 years earlier.

It’s very tidy, but nothing plays out that clearly. Elise is mean in the pilot, but she’s softened so immediately that she just becomes a variation on Poehler’s beloved Leslie (almost an anagram of “Elise”) Knope, an enthusiast in a job she takes more seriously than her colleagues do. Viswanathan plays Dylan as more loosely flighty than chaotic, which gives her very little room for the taming or development that it’s suggested she needs. I never quite got what Clare’s personality was supposed to be, because “rich” isn’t a real personality. And since Thomas doesn’t project as appreciably older than Viswanathan or Strazza, the stratification of these four women, each representing a different decade on life’s journey, doesn’t really emerge. (I also don’t understand what any of the characters do the rest of the year. But I guess I don’t understand what Bill Murray’s Trapper does when he isn’t counseling the kids in Meatballs either. And yes, Dig is basically Meatballs with fossils.)

It’s only Strazza (Paper Girls) who has a character with a fully discernible arc, written with enough specificity to lead to a fully developed performance. Yes, Patty is a broad and familiar type, but Strazza plays the bumbling naiveté to the hilt and, when the opportunity presents itself, Patty’s desire for her first real friend group and her first chance at love let Strazza ground the entire series. It’s Strazza’s show, so if she annoys you — some viewers will find her too broad, though I did not — that’s a problem.

Strazza is responsible for most of my laughs and most of the show’s effective emotional beats. I smiled a lot at Viswanathan’s inconsistently written, solidly delivered one-liners. Poehler is an entirely appealing straight-woman, and although I didn’t find Elise funny, I liked the romantic charge she brought to her scenes with Novak. I appreciated how Novak takes a character who starts off cartoonish and makes him into an odd kind of leading man, one who the series only rarely positions as a leading man. I guess that title goes to Laurie, at his funniest when he treats Neville as a bloviating companion to the actor’s adored run as Bertie Wooster on British TV’s Jeeves and Wooster.

Greek viewers who took umbrage at the lack of Greeks in Christopher Nolan’s The Odyssey will have more to be irritated by here: The biggest Greek role goes to the not-even-vaguely-Greek Novak, and there’s a heavy reliance on Greek stereotypes (several embodied by the far more Greek and far more amusing Jason Mantzoukas), even if they’re introduced to be mocked or debunked. Even Greece itself is played primarily by Italy and Universal Studios in Hollywood. The use of real locations in Greece and Italy comes across more as a pretext for a pleasant getaway for the cast and crew than anything that truly adds authenticity.

Some people will suggest that these are mere quibbles — the inconsistently written characters, sporadic laughs and superficial mystery — and that I had to dig for them. And, surely, the most glaring problem with Dig is its inferiority to previous Schur creations. That’s what you get for setting the bar high rather than low, or even somewhere subterranean. A pit, perhaps?

Read Entire Article
Chatroom